Cinesnatch

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Sunday, October 21, 2012

Movie Spoiler THE PAPERBOY (2012) - after review

Posted on 6:08 PM by Unknown
I caught The Paperboy the other night. The uneventful lengths I went to see it are detailed here. I was pretty excited to see something teeming in cinematic sexual energy with a less traditional approach in filmmaking from Lee Daniels and cinematographer Roberto Schaefer. And I was more than curious to see the polarizing film which showed at Cannes and divided critics. I was expecting to love or hate the Southern noir, but I didn't fall under either category. I did love the first sixty minutes or so and then it falls into a mess, revealing that a good chunk of the previous hour was full of red herrings. It left a lot for me to appreciate it, but it often felt hallow in nature, when it was striving to be so much more. Based on the novel by Peter Dexter (which he adapted with Daniels), the story involves Charlotte Bless (a peroxide, tanned Nicole Kidman at her sluttiest Ann-Margaret best), a deranged single gal in the late 1960s who falls in love with prisoner Hillary Van Wetter (John Cusack, who, in a role that didn't seem suited for him, actually doesn't suck) through correspondence. There ain't nothing more that she wants in life (so she thinks) than to have her brains fucked out all the time by Wetter. He's in prison as a convicted murder and two reporters Ward Jansen (Matthew McConaughey) and Yardley Acheman (David Oyelowo) take it upon themselves to overturn his sentencing. The central character is Ward's younger brother Jack (Zac Efron), the title character, whose occupation (care of his father) doesn't play such a large role in the film as that of The Driver. With a twist on the recent The Help, Jack shares a fond relationship with his nanny, who is also the maid, Anita Chester (Macy Gray). The vocally lethargic, but sassy woman narrates the film, for whatever reason (a telltale sign that filmmakers get lost in the editing room and begin to panic). While I'm not a fan of narration in films, its presence is mostly a wash.

The Van Wetter plotline is ancillary, for better or worse. There really is no whodunit mystery, more of a focus on the relationship between Charlotte and Jack. With the costumes, makeup, cars, and the various camera angles, the film has a look that feels like authentic 1960s Florida. Its politically incorrectness is refreshing and enlightening, while it deals with race relations, much moreso than its Help counterpart. This isn't no feel-good movie for white people, moreso a film about a bunch of adults who are fucked-up hot messes dealing with their own shit. Every character has their own agenda or skeletons in their closet, and when they all start to fall out at once and barrage the audience, the movie begins to get scattered and lose its juice. Rightly or wrongly so, the plot skims over certain elements rather hastily as it races for the finish line (and what a closing shot).

The casting of Cusack is smart in that he has an innocent enough face that you believe he may have not done it, but the actor plays him with an edge that keeps you wondering, which is important to egg the audience along, as it's ultimately insignificant. My only beef, however, is that Cusack doesn't quite have the sex appeal for Van Wetter, even though Kidman is such a good actress, she could you have convinced she wanted to hump a tree. She's brimming over in heat. Her accent is a little strange at first (as many like to point out with her American dialects), as if she is talking out of the lower part of her mouth (insert Third Lip joke here). But, she commits to the role, as you expect from Kidman and she goes the whole nine yards. So, it leaves me wondering if the story was pared down unnecessarily and inadvertently neutered her emotional attachment to Jack, because I wasn't feeling it.  The transition from her sexual attraction to Hillary to developing a fondness for Jack just isn't there.  She's all dark with little vulnerability (except in one scene towards the end between her and Cusack).  And it's imperative that you feel connected to her as a viewer, because the film relies on Zac Efron's shoulders as the film presses on. He's believable as the young innocent with no purpose in life other than to be in love with an older vamp who has him under his spell. But, his journey feels shallow and meaningless, as most everyone around him betrays him and his love for Charlotte is all that he has to hold onto.

I wouldn't expect too much, but I recommend it to those who trust my judgment in taste, as, essentially, it's imperfect, and quite likely that you will indeed love or hate it. Deeply flawed, I still give it a "B" for Daniels' somewhat audacious and pulpy style: worth one viewing.

Movie Spoiler Summary
The film starts out with someone interviewing Anita Chester (Macy Gray) about the murder of white racist Sheriff Thurmond Call (Danny Hanemann) during the 1960s (perhaps hastily added in post). She was the nanny/maid for the Jansen household, headed by W.W. (Scott Glenn), who is married to his second wife Ellen Guthrie (Nealla Gordon), stepmom to grown sons Jack (Zac Efron) and Ward (Matthew McConaughey). W.W. Jansen owns a Floridian newspaper. Son Ward is a reporter and Jack is The Paperboy. Anita is primarily the mother-figure and has a close and easy relationship to the boys.

The movie proper starts with Anita making light of Jack's privacy as they kid around with each other. In his office, W.W. and Ellen, who works for him as a reporter, watch Shirley Chisholm speak on television and Ellen reveals herself to be not so forward-thinking. She is exceptionally critical of Chisholm. W.W. is aware that son Ward is coming to town with his partner Yardley Acheman (David Oyelowo) to investigate the murder conviction of Hillary Van Wetter (John Cusack).  At the apartment of Charlotte Bless (Nicole Kidman), she discusses her new prison lover Hillary with her housemates while The Edge of Night plays on television.  Ward arrives with Yardley in a town that isn't the most welcoming to their cause.  (Yardley is a black man sporting a London accent, which will be important later.)  Jack picks them up and takes them to the Jansen household.  At an awkward dinner, Ellen is kind of a cunt and dodges questions about how she got from New York to small-town Florida.  The Jansen couple are surprised to learn that the Yardley is an actual writer.  Yardley believes Hillary is guilty ("It was a lynching, pure and simple"), but Ward believes "he has certain rights ... that the process disregarded."

The next day, Ward and Yardley prepare their case in the garage.  The trampy Charlotte arrives with a box full of correspondence and Jack is immediately enamored with her.

Jack drives Charlotte to the prison where her fiancee Hillary is located, and he shares the story of how he got kicked off his college swim team.  She starts to get horny thinking about Hillary and has a moment in front of Jack, before a guard kicks them off the premises.  Over narration, Anita explains Hillary's conviction as being pretty hallow.  Ward and company visit Weldon Pine, Hillary's attorney on the case.  The meeting gets tempestuous, to say the least.


While waiting to drive Charlotte and the gang, Jack fantasizes about her (the clip was released on the internet, ending with Kidman wearing a wedding veil and her lips approaching the camera in the direction of Jack).  His daydreams are interrupted and they all prepare to get in the car.  When Charlotte asks for everyone to roll up their windows to protect the integrity of Charlotte's hairstyle, Yardley protests, "I'm sweating like a pregnant nun back here."  They take off for prison to visit Hillary.  


There's a palpable sexual tension between Charlotte and Hillary and the convict asks her to spread her legs, rip off her panties, open her mouth seductively, and masturbate (the latter of which we don't actually see).  You'd think he was saving up for his spank bank, but being a prisoner and all, he cums in his pants.  A guard ends the telepathically-conjugal visit.  Ward and Jack visit Weldon Pine (Gary Clarke) about missing evidence.   He shares that Hillary once cut a deputy's thumb off over a traffic ticket.  "You can't do much without your thumb; it's what separates us from the primates.  A little thing like holding your wife's titty ..." and indicates a masturbation joke.

On the second visit to the jailhouse, Hillary is irate that Charlotte wore pants.  "Every God-damn man in here wears pants.  How am I supposed to tell you apart from them?"  He points out Ward's scar and shits on Yardley.  A non-plussed Yardley asks Charlotte, "Where does one gets pants like that from anyway?"  Anita narrates that Jack becomes jealous of Charlotte's obsession with Hillary; she also mentions that Jack starts to wonder about his brother's relationship to Yardley.

The Urination Scene
At the beach, Jack reads Lolita while Charlotte suntans.  She tells the infatuated Jack, "I'm not going to blow a friendship over a stupid little blow job."  When she points out some girls nearby she thinks would be interested in servicing Jack, he squashes her suggestion.  She responds, "Well, it's a good thing you're not in prison, because you wouldn't have a choice there."  Angry, he tells her to fuck off and swims out into the ocean.  After getting massively attacked by a bunch of jellyfish, he barely swims back ashore, where some strangers agonize overly the badly hurt Jack.  Charlotte barges in, "Hey, did you say you're going to piss on him?  What are you doing to him? ... shut the fuck up!  Get the fuck out of here!  I can see this ... I will slap your face, get the fuck out of here ... I said I will kick your ass.  Move it!  IF ANYONE'S GONNA PISS ON HIM IT'S GONNA BE ME!  He don't like strangers peeing on him.  Come on, come on."  In the much talked about and spoiled moment, Charlotte urinates on Jack (it what could have and probably was simulated and involved a body double).  "Come on," Charlotte encourages herself to get a steady stream out.  Later, while Anita tends to him in his bedroom, Jack comments on the smell around him.  She replies, "That's because that blonde lady peed all over your face."  The incident makes W.W.'s newspaper, which infuriates son Jack, who picks a fight with Yardley and calls him "nigger" in front of Anita.  Charlotte's solution: "He needs to get laid ... he's sexually repressed."  Yardley, "'Sexually repressed' says a forty-year-old woman who is obsessed with prison cock."  Charlotte rather nonchalantly responds, "That's not nice."

Jack drives Ward to the prison where he questions Hillary about the victim.  They take a motor boat out to a swamp where Hillary's uncle Tyree (Ned Bellamy) lives, while Charlotte and Yardley investigate another matter involving a golf course.  Tyree rambles on about some condo dealings and is pretty backwoods and threatening.  He tries to intimidate the boys by eviscerating an alligator hanging from a rope.  He then eats ice cream with his family, before he becomes more compliant and provides Hillary with an alibi.  Eugene (Adam Sibley) comes out of the shack and Jack recognizes him from the prison before the brothers leave; not that it means anything.  They arrive at their vehicle to find the tires slashed.  Back at the garage, Yardley confronts Jack because he's wearing his clothes.  Yardley brings back information he ascertained from an anonymous source concerning some golf course that bolsters their case (which are probably all lies).  Jack and Charlotte talk in the rain and they dance, reminiscent of Kidman's scene with Joaquin Phoenix in To Die For.  Anita explains over narration that Yardley was ready to leave, after helping Ward out.  Jack apologizes to Anita after she prompts him.  Ward speaks to some guy named John who wants out of the business of proving that Hillary may be not-guilty.  W.W. is worried about running the story and losing advertisers.  Jack gets in a barb about sensationalist reporting being more acceptable to print than journalism that makes a community feel uncomfortable.

Ellen asks Anita to clean up a broken glass, when she is clearly made up to to look nice and her shift is over.  W.W. announces his engagement to the recently promoted editor-in-chief Ellen and Jack takes his mother's ring off Ellen's finger.  Yardley leaves and goes back to Miami, but Anita explains over narration that "Ward never believed Yardley's story, building permits, and anonymous sources" and took Charlotte and Jack back to the beach Yardley previously visited with Charlotte.  At a bar with Charlotte and Jack, the white Ward conspicuously hits on a couple of black men.  Jack offers Charlotte his mother's ring.  There's a montage that is part Jack daydreaming about Charlotte mixed with allusions to Ward's whereabouts.  Charlotte wakes Jack up as Ward is in trouble.  They find him hog-tied with chains and his face bashed in.  He's not only violently beaten in an uncompromising position, but his body lays on a large stretch of plastic covering.  He was going to be murdered for being gay.

After Ward is safely recovering at the hospital, Charlotte and Jack talk and she finally agrees to make love to Jack just once.  Jack explains that he's hurt that his brother didn't share with him that he's gay.  They part ways after Charlotte gives him the ring back.  Jack travels to see Yardley in Miami.  He insists that he remove his brother's name from the article if Yardley won't "get all the facts straight."  It turns out that Yardley is not English, but put on the act and took advantage of Ward's predilection to black men for professional expediency.  Yardley is unconcerned at that point if Hillary is guilty or not.  Jack learns from Yardley over the phone that Hillary is getting out of jail.  Jack sends Charlotte his mother's ring.  While Barbara Bain is on the television, Hillary arrives at Charlotte's and has extremely rough sex with the terrified, but slightly exhilarated woman. Hillary moves Charlotte out to uncle Tyree's in the swamp, much to her chagrin on various levels.

Life on the swamp is like being in prison and she gives Cousin Alice (Corrina Lyons) a letter to send to Jack, so he'll save her.  (She likes to create her own messes, regardless of whom she involves.)  Jack visits the disheveled Ward, who informs him that Yardley has gone on to become a famed journalist.  Jack convinces Ward to shower up for W.W. and Ellen's wedding, when he announces, "Mama always said, 'You better be right and be last, before you going to be first and be wrong, boy.'"  Jack visits Anita in the kitchen of the reception.  She no longer works for W.W. and gives him a letter from Charlotte hoping Jack will save her from Hillary.  The cook barks orders at his staff; Jack tries to make him feel as small as he treated the women and leaves.  Ward and Jack go out to the swamp to find Charlotte to bring her to the wedding reception.  Ward injures himself on an electric fence.  Hillary beats Charlotte to death.  In a graphic moment, Hillary fights Ward and slits his throat.  Jack runs away and Hillary corners him at the end of the dock.  In a scary moment, Jack jumps into the alligator-infested swamp and swims around avoiding Hillary for twelve (!) hours or so in scenes interspersed with clips from Jack's college-swimming days.  The next day, the boat motor dies.  Jack manage to retrieve both bodies and haul them back to a boat.  Anita explains through voice narration (apparently, she is no longer being interviewed about the sheriff's murder, like that was ever important) that Hillary was convicted and executed for the double murder.  "Nobody ever found out who murdered Sheriff Caul."  The final image is of Matthew McConaughey and Nicole Kidman lying next to each other, dead inside a speedboat, while Zac Efron powers his way through a swamp.

Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in 2012 Film Review, Movie Spoiler | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Happy Birthday Suit: Cameron Diaz
    I fell behind on the Happy Birthday Suit(less) series.  Its days are numbered anyway, so to speak, since I'm only focusing on post-World...
  • Movie Spoiler Summary: UNTHINKABLE
    Unthinkable concerns an interrogator who uses questionable techniques on a Muslim man who may or may have not planted three strategically-pl...
  • Movie Spoiler: Fatal Attraction
    Fatal Attraction was landmark horror-thriller that dealt with marital infidelity involving a publishing lawyer and book editor.   The R-rat...
  • Norbit: Movie Spoiler Summary
    Six years ago, after over twenty-five years in the business, Eddie Murphy received his very first Oscar nomination for Dreamgirls as Jimmy....
  • Opening Title Sequence: My Best Friend's Wedding
    In 1997, Julia Roberts returned to her bread and butter after three years of underperforming at the box-office and found a massive hit (that...
  • Movie Spoiler THE SKELETON KEY (preceded by capsule review)
    The Skeleton Key , the title of which is a red herring attempt to suggest a mysterious tone, is one of those nothing special films you may h...
  • Movie Spoiler THE PAPERBOY (2012) - after review
    I caught The Paperboy the other night. The uneventful lengths I went to see it are detailed here . I was pretty excited to see something ...
  • Movie Spoiler MAGIC MIKE (2012) starring Matthew McConaughey- after review
    Magic Mike : Movie Spoiler Summary (after capsule review).   Steven Soderbergh announced he was going to retire soon, but he shows no signs ...
  • Movie Spoiler DOLORES CLAIBORNE (1995) starring Kathy Bates - after review
    Dolores Claiborne: Movie Spoiler Summary (after capsule review).  Thanks to the success of Kathy Bates' Best Actress Oscar-winning turn ...
  • MOVIE SPOILER The Cabin in the Woods (review follows)
    Movie Spoiler: The Cabin in the Woods  (Review at the end of post).  Sitterson (Oscar nominated Richard Jenkins from The Visitor ) and Hadle...

Categories

  • 2011 Film Review (2)
  • 2012 Film Review (35)
  • 2012 Hola Mexico Film Festival (2)
  • 2012 Hollywood Fringe Festival (17)
  • 2012 Movie Review (10)
  • 2013 (1)
  • 68 Cent (1)
  • Actress Retrospective (30)
  • AHF (1)
  • Ahmanson (1)
  • Al Pacino (1)
  • Amanda Bynes (1)
  • Amanda Seyfried (1)
  • Amy Adams (2)
  • An Evening With ... (1)
  • Angelina Jolie (3)
  • Animated Feature (1)
  • Anne Hathaway (13)
  • Annette Bening (3)
  • Arbitrage (1)
  • Barbra Streisand (1)
  • Best Actor (2)
  • Best Actor 2013 (2)
  • Best Actress (18)
  • Best Actress 2012 (9)
  • Best Actress 2013 (39)
  • Best Actress 2014 (1)
  • Best Adapted Screenplay (2)
  • Best Animated Feature (1)
  • Best Director (5)
  • Best Documentary (1)
  • Best Documentary Short (1)
  • Best Live Action Short (1)
  • Best Original Screenplay (3)
  • Best Picture (10)
  • Best Sound Editing (1)
  • Best Sound Mixing (1)
  • Best Supporting Actor (1)
  • Best Supporting Actor 2013 (2)
  • Best Supporting Actress 2013 (5)
  • Box Office (1)
  • bradley cooper (1)
  • Brooke Shields (1)
  • Cameron Diaz (1)
  • Cannes 2012 (1)
  • Carey Mulligan (1)
  • Casting (2)
  • Cate Blanchett (4)
  • Catherine Zeta-Jones (1)
  • Charlize Theron (2)
  • Cher (1)
  • ChloĆ« Sevigny (1)
  • Cinematography (1)
  • Claire Danes (1)
  • Costume Design (1)
  • Czech (1)
  • Dakota Fanning (1)
  • Dan Johnson Review (8)
  • Daniel Day-Lewis (2)
  • Demi Moore (1)
  • Denzel Washington (1)
  • Diane Keaton (1)
  • Editing (1)
  • Elaine Stritch (1)
  • Elizabeth Olsen (1)
  • Elizabeth Reaser (1)
  • Ellen Barkin (1)
  • Emily Blunt (1)
  • Emma Thompson (2)
  • Emma Watson (2)
  • Faye Dunaway (1)
  • Felicity Jones (1)
  • Film Review (8)
  • Frances McDormand (1)
  • Gay (3)
  • Geffen Playhouse (1)
  • Glenn Close (2)
  • goldie hawn (1)
  • Greta Gerwig (1)
  • Gwyneth Paltrow (1)
  • Halle Berry (1)
  • Helen Hunt (4)
  • Helena Bonham Carter (1)
  • Hilary Swank (3)
  • Hit Me with Your Best Shot (15)
  • HIV Awareness Month July (1)
  • Holly Hunter (3)
  • Interview (5)
  • Jacki Weaver (5)
  • Jennifer Aniston (1)
  • Jennifer Garner (1)
  • Jennifer Grey (1)
  • Jennifer Lawrence (8)
  • Jessica Biel (1)
  • Jessica Chastain (3)
  • Jessica Lange (1)
  • Joaquin Phoenix (1)
  • Jodie Foster (2)
  • Jonah Hill (1)
  • Judi Dench (2)
  • Julia Roberts (4)
  • Julianne Moore (2)
  • Julie Christie (1)
  • Julie Delpy (1)
  • Kate Beckinsale (2)
  • Kate Winslet (2)
  • Katie Holmes (2)
  • Kaya Scodelario (1)
  • Keira Knightley (2)
  • Keri Russell (1)
  • Kirsten Dunst (1)
  • Kristen Stewart (3)
  • Kristen Wiig (2)
  • L.A. Pix (2)
  • LA Film Festival (4)
  • LA Film Festival 2012 (3)
  • Lena Olin (1)
  • Leonardo DiCaprio (1)
  • Lindsay Lohan (2)
  • Los Angeles (1)
  • Maggie Gyllenhaal (1)
  • Margo Martindale (1)
  • Marion Cotillard (2)
  • Mark Ruffalo (1)
  • Mary Elizabeth Winstead (1)
  • Matthew McConaughey (1)
  • Meryl Streep (5)
  • Michelle Pfeiffer (1)
  • Mila Kunis (2)
  • Misc. (21)
  • Movie Posters (1)
  • Movie Spoiler (55)
  • Naomi Watts (3)
  • Natalie Portman (2)
  • Newport Beach Film Festival (1)
  • Nicholas Jarecki (1)
  • Nicole Kidman (12)
  • Opening This Weekend (14)
  • Opening Title Sequence (8)
  • Oscar (8)
  • Oscar 2012 (29)
  • Oscar 2013 (31)
  • Oscar Outlook 2012 (11)
  • Oscar Predictions (3)
  • Oscar Preview (5)
  • Oscar Revisionism (23)
  • Outfest 2012 (3)
  • Outfest Review (6)
  • Page to Screen (17)
  • Predictions (2)
  • Previews (31)
  • Production Design (1)
  • Rachel McAdams (1)
  • Rachel Weisz (1)
  • Reader Request Review (1)
  • Reese Witherspoon (1)
  • ReOscaring (2)
  • Review (1)
  • Richard Gere (1)
  • Robin Weigert (1)
  • Robin Wright (1)
  • Rosie O'Donnell (1)
  • Sally Field (2)
  • Sally Hawkins (1)
  • Sally Kirkland (1)
  • Samantha Morton (1)
  • Sandra Bullock (2)
  • Scarlett Johansson (1)
  • Scene By Scene (1)
  • Score (1)
  • Screenplay Review (1)
  • Script Review (13)
  • Shailene Woodley (1)
  • Shirley MacLaine (2)
  • Sigourney Weaver (1)
  • Sissy Spacek (1)
  • SNL (12)
  • Spoiler Summary (2)
  • Susan Sarandon (1)
  • Sweepstakes (1)
  • Theatre Review (55)
  • Tina Fey (1)
  • Tom Cruise (3)
  • Trailers (10)
  • TV (1)
  • Vanessa Redgrave (1)
  • Viola Davis (1)
  • Whoopi Goldberg (1)
  • Winona Ryder (1)
  • Zoe Saldana (1)

Blog Archive

  • ►  2013 (171)
    • ►  September (5)
    • ►  August (6)
    • ►  July (6)
    • ►  June (3)
    • ►  May (12)
    • ►  April (36)
    • ►  March (9)
    • ►  February (52)
    • ►  January (42)
  • ▼  2012 (329)
    • ►  December (27)
    • ►  November (22)
    • ▼  October (30)
      • Best Gay/Gay Adjacent 2013?
      • Winona For ... Now (Happy Birthday Suitless)
      • Movie Spoiler CLOUD ATLAS (2012) starring Tom Hank...
      • Movie Spoiler ARBITRAGE (2012) starring Richard Ge...
      • Review: Snow White and the Huntsman
      • Movie Spoiler ANGEL (1984) - after review
      • Best Actor 2012: Daniel Day-Lewis Vs. Denzel Washi...
      • Movie Spoiler OCTOBER BABY (2012) - after short re...
      • Film Review: Argo
      • Movie Spoiler RED LIGHTS (2012)
      • Best Actress: October Predictions
      • Movie Spoiler THE PAPERBOY (2012) - after review
      • Los Angeles Theatre Review: Rock of Abandon
      • SNL Review: Bruno Mars
      • Review: End of Watch
      • KStew as Prophet
      • Joaquin Phoenix Pops Off Out of the Ashes
      • When Life Gives You Lemons, Make Muslimade
      • SNL Review: Christina Applegate #2
      • Movie Spoiler BEASTS OF THE SOUTHERN WILD (2012)
      • Los Angeles Theatre Review: Room 105 (at the MACHA...
      • Can We Stop Pretending? Anne Has Oscar in the Bag
      • Los Angeles Theatre Review: Reclining Nude on La C...
      • SNL Review: Daniel Craig
      • Los Angeles Theatre Review: LORCAbaret
      • Movie Spoile LOOPER (2012) starring Bruce Willis -...
      • Movie Spoiler PROMETHEUS (2012)
      • Happy Birthday Suit: Cameron Diaz
      • DiCaprio Unchained
      • Movie Spoiler KILLER JOE (2012) starring Matthew M...
    • ►  September (21)
    • ►  August (9)
    • ►  July (30)
    • ►  June (59)
    • ►  May (56)
    • ►  April (51)
    • ►  March (24)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile